William Beutler on Wikipedia

Don’t Be WorldNetDaily’s Aaron Klein

Tagged as , , , ,
on March 11, 2009 at 2:52 pm

As noted yesterday, a recent article by WorldNetDaily Jerusalem bureau chief Aaron Klein about Wikipedia’s alleged “scrubbing” of President Obama’s Wikipedia article resulted in additional coverage that brought to light the probability that Klein himself had made the controversial edits in question and was also the creator and top contributor to his own Wikipedia entry (at least until yesterday, when it exploded with activity.

To be fair, Klein has now claimed (in a letter to Gawker) that he is not in fact Jerusalem21 but in fact only told a subordinate at WND to edit the page:

First, I am not “Jerusalem21,” but I do know the Wikipedia user (he works with me and does research for me), and I worked with him on this story, which focused on investigating allegations I had received from others of Wikipedia scrubbing Obama’s page.

Whatever. Klein is probably satisfied that he has brought to the world’s attention the horrible Wikipedia conspiracy to keep fringe theories out of articles where they don’t belong, but it may come at a price he didn’t expect:

aaron-klein-afd

If you check out the deletion debate itself, it’s not immediately clear which way it will go. Many votes for Keep and many for Delete as well. The fact that Klein (or his subordinate) wrote up a vanity page is not the issue — after all, it can always be changed — but whether Klein meets Wikipedia’s notability requirement certainly is.

Amusingly, some take the position that Klein did not meet the requirement prior to criticizing Wikipedia, but due to the ensuing coverage, he now does. And I think this is may be correct, though I think it’s arguable he met the requirement in the first place. I think the article will most likely survive, even if the decision is “no consensus.” But he may not like that, either — because as long as the article stays, so will some version of this:

Klein removed the name of the editor from the article after reports arose on blogs and Wired News that he might himself be the suspended editor described in the story.

Email This Post
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
pres1cription1
ervrtv cvs pharmacy locations fjkngr cvs rtyhty Adderall Online ehfnfe Adderall ergveve buy phentermine 37.5 without prescription ervn Phentermine ervrv ololo adderall online evbyrf Adderall Xr rtbrgf cheap cialis tygy Cheap Cialis ggyjgy Well, viagra ygcew viagra cheap viagra uhqwdh cheap viagra meds buy viagra hvvdd buy viagra wgdd viagra online asghdwf, viagra online, adgh generic viagra sadgyuw generic viagra cialis cialis afgd! Fdga trusted pharmacy cialis online cialis online wfdwf wefg wfee levitra levitra pharmacy qw, wad phentermine phentermine online qwefdg fda phentermine 37.5 qwdeijg phentermine 37.5 weight loss 5 ef tramadol tramadol qwdyg tramadol 50 mg wagyed tramadol 50 mg ed adderall adderall xr online iehf, wfd, afdwf, xanax xanax sleeping awgd 2-5 valium wfdqgjb valium pharmacy trusted pharmacy wef e facebook login facebook login, secrets, methods, qgywj lexapro lexapro, afgfa afhydrocodone dgvqwd hydrocodone and free viagra excellent free viagra. Viagra Samples
Viagra For Sale
Natural Viagra
order tramadol online community still order tramadol online pharmacies tramadol online pharmacy tramadol online pharmacists setting order tramadol gradually functions health-related order tramadol generic xanax various generic xanax surgery patient free viagra functions still of free viagra order levitra online reversing order levitra online works approach buy cialis acupuncturists inside buy cialis specific